What Is Pay G Understanding Models Applications And Technologies

Published

Table of Contents

Pay-as-you-go (PayG) has revolutionized how consumers and businesses access services by aligning costs directly with usage, eliminating the rigidities of traditional subscription or upfront payment models. From prepaid mobile plans to smart energy grids and on-demand software trials, PayG transforms financial barriers into scalable, flexible solutions—particularly in sectors where predictability of demand or budget constraints pose challenges. This model not only democratizes access to essential services but also introduces dynamic pricing, real-time billing, and automated settlement processes that redefine provider-consumer relationships. By examining its technical underpinnings, industry-specific applications, and socioeconomic impact, we uncover how PayG bridges affordability with innovation across global markets.

The evolution of PayG reflects broader shifts in technology and consumer behavior, with milestones spanning mobile telephony in the 1990s to blockchain-enabled microtransactions today. Unlike conventional models that lock users into long-term contracts or require lump-sum payments, PayG thrives on modularity—allowing providers to adjust pricing based on real-time data while users retain control over spending. Whether in telecom, utilities, or SaaS, the model’s adaptability extends to emerging economies, where it addresses financial exclusion by enabling incremental payments. However, its implementation demands robust infrastructure, from IoT-enabled metering to fraud-resistant billing systems, alongside regulatory compliance to ensure transparency and trust.

what is payg

Definition and Core Concept of Pay-as-You-Go (PayG)

Pay-as-you-go (PayG) represents a consumption-based pricing model where users pay exclusively for the resources, services, or products they utilize, rather than committing to fixed-term contracts or upfront payments. This model aligns costs directly with actual usage, offering scalability and financial predictability for both providers and consumers. Its adoption spans industries such as telecommunications, utilities, and software-as-a-service (SaaS), each adapting PayG to address unique operational and customer needs.

The PayG framework fundamentally challenges traditional subscription or upfront payment models by eliminating over-provisioning and reducing financial barriers for users. While subscriptions require long-term commitments and upfront payments demand full payment before service access, PayG enables granular billing, dynamic resource allocation, and minimal user lock-in. This distinction is critical in industries where demand fluctuates or user needs are unpredictable.

Pay-as-You-Go Models Across Industries

PayG implementations vary significantly depending on the sector, with telecom, utilities, and SaaS platforms adopting distinct approaches tailored to their operational dynamics.

Telecom Industry
In telecommunications, PayG is synonymous with prepaid services, where users top up their accounts with credit proportional to minutes, data, or SMS usage. Providers like Vodafone and Airtel leverage this model to cater to budget-conscious users in emerging markets, where credit constraints limit subscription-based adoption. The model relies on real-time usage tracking via SIM cards or dedicated PayG platforms, with billing cycles often shorter than monthly (e.g., daily or weekly top-ups).

Utilities Sector
Utilities such as electricity, water, and gas providers employ PayG through smart meters that measure consumption in real time. Users pay for energy or water consumed, with dynamic pricing tiers (e.g., peak vs. off-peak rates) incentivizing efficient usage. Companies like British Gas and Enel X use PayG to reduce billing disputes and improve demand forecasting. The technical backbone includes IoT-enabled meters transmitting data to centralized billing systems, which generate invoices based on usage intervals (e.g., hourly or half-hourly).

SaaS Platforms
In software, PayG aligns with "usage-based pricing," where users pay for API calls, storage, or computational resources consumed. Platforms like AWS Lambda, Google Cloud Functions, and Stripe’s Pay-as-you-go billing operate on this principle, charging per millisecond of execution or gigabyte of data processed. This model is particularly advantageous for startups and enterprises with variable workloads, as it eliminates over-provisioning and aligns costs with business activity.

Comparison of PayG with Traditional Models

The following table contrasts PayG with subscription and upfront payment models across key dimensions, illustrating its operational and financial advantages.
Metric Pay-as-You-Go (PayG) Subscription Model Upfront Payment Model
Payment Structure Billed per unit of consumption (e.g., per minute, per kWh, per API call). No fixed fees. Fixed monthly/annual fee regardless of usage. Often includes tiered limits. Full payment required before service access. No incremental billing.
Cost Flexibility High. Costs scale directly with usage; ideal for variable demand. Moderate. Costs are predictable but may exceed actual usage (wasted capacity). Low. Costs are static and may be prohibitive for low-usage scenarios.
Risk for Provider Moderate to high. Revenue depends on consistent usage; risk of underutilization. Low to moderate. Recurring revenue stabilizes cash flow but exposes churn risk. Low. Upfront payments guarantee revenue but deter price-sensitive users.
User Commitment None. Users can pause or terminate service without penalties. High. Contracts often require 12–24 month commitments with cancellation fees. High. Full payment binds users to the service until consumption is exhausted.
Use Cases
  • Telecom prepaid plans (e.g., mobile data, voice minutes).
  • Utility smart meters (e.g., electricity, water).
  • Cloud computing (e.g., AWS Lambda, Google Cloud).
  • IoT device connectivity (e.g., LoRaWAN networks).
  • Microtransactions in gaming or digital services.
  • Streaming services (e.g., Netflix, Spotify).
  • Software licenses (e.g., Adobe Creative Cloud).
  • Gym memberships or SaaS tools with fixed feature sets.
  • High-end hardware purchases (e.g., enterprise servers).
  • One-time software licenses (e.g., Microsoft Office perpetual).
  • Bulk utility purchases (e.g., industrial gas contracts).

Historical Evolution of Pay-as-You-Go

The PayG model emerged as a response to economic constraints and technological limitations, evolving alongside advancements in metering, digital billing, and cloud infrastructure. Below is a timeline of key milestones across industries:

1980s–1990s: Telecom Prepaid Revolution

  • 1984: Japan’s NTT launches the first prepaid mobile phone service, targeting business travelers with limited credit.
  • 1994: Vodafone UK introduces the "Pay & Go" service, enabling prepaid mobile subscriptions in Europe. This model democratized mobile access in developing markets by eliminating credit checks.
  • 1999: GSM Association standardizes prepaid SIM cards, accelerating global adoption.
  • 2000s: Utilities and Smart Metering

  • 2003: UK’s Department of Trade and Industry mandates smart meters for all households by 2020, shifting from estimated to real-time billing.
  • 2008: Google introduces "Pay-as-you-go" pricing for its App Engine cloud platform, charging users for CPU, bandwidth, and storage consumed.
  • 2010: Amazon Web Services (AWS) launches Lambda in 2014, but its foundational PayG model for cloud services gains traction with the rise of serverless computing.
  • 2010s–Present: Digital and IoT Expansion

  • 2015: Stripe introduces Pay-as-you-go billing for its payment processing services, aligning costs with transaction volumes.
  • 2017: LoRa Alliance standardizes low-power, wide-area (LPWA) networks, enabling PayG pricing for IoT connectivity (e.g., $0.01 per device/day).
  • 2020: COVID-19 accelerates PayG adoption in utilities, with providers offering temporary discounts or usage caps to vulnerable customers.
  • 2023: AI-driven dynamic pricing emerges in PayG models, with platforms like AWS adjusting costs based on real-time demand (e.g., higher prices during peak hours).
  • The evolution reflects a broader trend toward democratization of access, operational efficiency, and data-driven pricing, with PayG becoming the default for industries where usage patterns are unpredictable or user needs are diverse.

    Technical Operation of Pay-as-You-Go

    PayG systems rely on real-time monitoring, metered billing, and automated settlement to ensure accurate and efficient transactions. The technical workflow varies by industry but typically involves the following components:

    1. Usage Tracking: Devices or software meters consumption (e.g., smart meters for electricity, API gateways for cloud services).
    2. Data Aggregation: Usage data is transmitted to a central system (e.g., via cellular networks, IoT protocols like MQTT, or direct API calls).
    3. Billing Engine: Algorithms process raw data into invoices, applying tariffs, discounts, or dynamic pricing rules.
    4. Payment Processing: Users are billed via automated systems (e.g., mobile wallets, credit cards, or prepaid credit top-ups).
    5. Settlement: Providers reconcile payments with usage records, often integrating with ERP or CRM systems.

    Example: Smart Meter PayG System

    A residential smart meter in a PayG electricity

    what is payg - Ilustrasi 2

    Industry Applications and Case Studies of Pay-as-You-Go (PayG) Models

    The Pay-as-You-Go (PayG) model has revolutionized access to goods and services across diverse sectors by decoupling upfront costs from usage, thereby enabling financial flexibility and scalability. Its implementation varies significantly depending on industry dynamics, consumer behavior, and technological infrastructure. Below are three distinct real-world examples demonstrating PayG’s adaptability, followed by comparative analyses of its B2B and B2C applications, socioeconomic impact in emerging markets, and emerging niche industries.

    Three Real-World PayG Implementations Across Sectors

    The mechanics of PayG differ by sector, often tailored to address unique pain points such as affordability, accessibility, or resource constraints. Below are three case studies highlighting successful deployments in telecommunications, renewable energy, and software services.

    1. Mobile Telephony: Prepaid and Micro-Payment Plans
    Mechanics:
    PayG in telecommunications is exemplified by prepaid mobile services, where users purchase airtime or data in small, incremental amounts. Operators like Airtel in India and MTN in Africa leverage PayG to serve low-income users by allowing top-ups via mobile money (e.g., M-Pesa), cash at retail outlets, or USSD codes. Usage is monitored in real-time, with balances deducted dynamically. Airtel’s "Airtel Money" extends this model to financial services, enabling micro-transactions for payments, bill settlements, and remittances.

    Target Users:
    Primarily unbanked or underbanked populations in developing economies, including daily wage earners, small traders, and rural communities. The model also appeals to migrant workers who require flexible, location-independent connectivity.

    Success Metrics:

  • India: Airtel’s prepaid subscriber base grew to 400+ million by 2023, with 80% of rural users relying on PayG plans (TRAI reports).
  • Africa: MTN’s PayG data bundles in Nigeria and Ghana accounted for 60% of total data revenue in 2022, with average revenue per user (ARPU) stabilizing at $1.5–$3/month (GSMA Intelligence).
  • Financial Inclusion: Mobile money transactions via PayG surpassed $1.5 trillion annually in Sub-Saharan Africa by 2023 (World Bank), with 70% of transactions under $5.
  • Key Innovation:
    Integration with mobile money ecosystems (e.g., M-Pesa, MoMo) eliminated reliance on traditional banking, reducing friction for cash-based economies.

    2. Renewable Energy: Solar Microgrids in Off-Grid Communities
    Mechanics:
    PayG solar systems, deployed by companies like M-KOPA Solar (Kenya/Tanzania) and BBOXX (India/Bangladesh), allow households to purchase solar home systems (SHS) in small, weekly or monthly installments via mobile payments. Devices include solar panels, batteries, and LED lights, with usage tracked via IoT-enabled meters. Payments are linked to energy consumption, and users can upgrade or pause plans as needed.

    Target Users:
    Off-grid households in rural areas of Sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, where 770 million people lack electricity (IEA). Target demographics include smallholder farmers, informal workers, and low-income families prioritizing immediate energy access over long-term ownership.

    Success Metrics:

  • M-KOPA Solar: Served 2.5 million customers across East Africa by 2023, with 95%+ repayment rates and average payback periods of 12–18 months (M-KOPA Annual Report).
  • BBOXX: Expanded to 1.2 million customers in India and Bangladesh, with 85% of users reporting increased income due to extended working hours (BBOXX Impact Report 2022).
  • Energy Access: PayG solar reduced kerosene lamp usage by 90% in M-KOPA’s customer base, cutting health risks and CO₂ emissions by 1.5 tons/year per household (IRENA).
  • Key Innovation:
    Dynamic pricing tiers based on usage (e.g., basic lighting vs. TV/phone charging) and flexible repayment options (e.g., pause during harvest failures) improved affordability.

    3. Software-as-a-Service (SaaS): Freemium and Usage-Based Trials
    Mechanics:
    SaaS providers like Slack, Zoom, and HubSpot employ PayG through freemium models (free tier with usage limits) and pay-per-usage pricing for enterprise clients. For example:

  • Zoom offers a free plan with 40-minute limits, while businesses pay per minute of meeting time or hosted participant.
  • HubSpot’s PayG CRM charges based on number of contacts, deals, or support tickets, with no long-term contracts.
  • AWS Activate provides free-tier cloud credits for startups, scaling to PayG based on compute/storage usage.
  • Target Users:

  • B2C: Individual professionals (e.g., freelancers, students) testing tools before committing.
  • B2B: Startups and SMEs with variable workloads (e.g., seasonal businesses) or uncertain cash flows.
  • Success Metrics:

  • Zoom: PayG accounted for 30% of total revenue in 2023, with enterprise PayG plans growing 40% YoY (Zoom Earnings Report).
  • Slack: 75% of free-tier users converted to paid plans within 12 months, with PayG usage-based pricing driving 20% of SMB revenue (Slack Business Update).
  • AWS: 90% of Activate program participants scaled to PayG within 24 months, with average savings of $10K/year (AWS Customer Case Studies).
  • Key Innovation:
    AI-driven usage forecasting (e.g., HubSpot’s "Predictive Lead Scoring") tailors PayG plans to business growth stages, reducing churn.

    Comparison of PayG in B2B vs. B2C

    The adoption and operational challenges of PayG differ markedly between business and consumer markets, influenced by payment frequency, scalability, and adoption barriers. The following table synthesizes key distinctions:

    what is payg - Ilustrasi 3

    Technological and Infrastructure Requirements for Pay-as-You-Go Systems

    Pay-as-You-Go (PayG) models rely on a robust, interconnected technology stack to enable real-time billing, usage tracking, and seamless transactions. The infrastructure must support scalability, security, and interoperability across diverse industries, from energy utilities to software subscriptions. A layered breakdown of the technology stack—frontend, backend, integration, and security—reveals how these components interact to facilitate microtransactions, fraud prevention, and dynamic pricing. Additionally, emerging technologies like blockchain, IoT, and edge computing are reshaping PayG by introducing decentralization, real-time analytics, and localized processing, though they also introduce challenges such as latency, regulatory compliance, and infrastructure dependencies.

    Layered Technology Stack for Pay-as-You-Go Systems

    The architecture of a PayG system is divided into four critical layers, each serving distinct functions while maintaining seamless communication. The frontend interfaces directly with end-users, providing intuitive dashboards for tracking consumption, adjusting plans, and initiating payments. The backend houses the core logic, including billing engines, fraud detection algorithms, and customer data management, ensuring accuracy and compliance. Integration layers bridge external systems—such as payment gateways, IoT sensors, and third-party APIs—while security protocols safeguard transactions against breaches and ensure adherence to global standards like GDPR and PCI-DSS.

    Frontend Components
    The user-facing layer must deliver real-time visibility into consumption patterns, payment statuses, and usage limits. Key elements include:

  • Mobile and Web Applications: Responsive interfaces with push notifications for alerts (e.g., low balance warnings, dynamic pricing updates).
  • Smart Device Dashboards: Embedded UIs in IoT devices (e.g., smart meters, connected cars) displaying instantaneous usage data and cost estimates.
  • Self-Service Portals: Features for plan customization, historical billing reviews, and dispute resolution.
  • Accessibility Compliance: Support for screen readers, multilingual interfaces, and offline modes for regions with unstable connectivity.
  • Backend Components
    The backend orchestrates the operational backbone of PayG, requiring high availability and low-latency processing. Critical subsystems include:

  • Billing Engines: Microservices that calculate usage-based charges in real time, support multiple currencies, and handle reconciliation for discrepancies.
  • Fraud Detection: Machine learning models analyzing transaction patterns to flag anomalies (e.g., sudden spikes in usage, duplicate payments).
  • Customer Relationship Management (CRM): Unified profiles linking payment histories, support tickets, and loyalty metrics to personalize offers.
  • Data Warehousing: Scalable databases (e.g., NoSQL for unstructured IoT data) storing raw usage logs, transaction records, and analytics for predictive modeling.
  • Integration Layers
    PayG systems depend on seamless interoperability with external platforms to enable automated workflows. Key integration points are:

  • Payment Gateways: APIs for processing microtransactions via credit cards, digital wallets (e.g., Apple Pay, M-Pesa), or cryptocurrencies (e.g., Bitcoin for peer-to-peer energy trading).
  • IoT Sensor Networks: Protocols like MQTT or LoRaWAN for low-power device communication, transmitting meter readings or vehicle telemetry to backend systems.
  • Telecom and Utility APIs: Partnerships with providers to validate SIM card usage (e.g., mobile data PayG) or electricity consumption (e.g., smart grid data feeds).
  • ERP and Accounting Systems: Synchronization with tools like SAP or QuickBooks for financial reporting and tax compliance.
  • Security Infrastructure
    Data integrity and user trust are paramount in PayG, where financial transactions occur in near real time. Security measures include:

  • End-to-End Encryption: TLS 1.3 for data in transit and AES-256 for stored customer data, with tokenization to mask sensitive payment details.
  • Compliance Frameworks:
  • GDPR: Anonymization of personal data, user consent management, and right-to-erasure mechanisms.
  • PCI-DSS: Secure handling of cardholder data, with tokenization replacing raw PAN (Primary Account Number) storage.
  • ISO 27001: Risk assessments for physical and digital assets, including third-party vendor audits.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Biometric verification or hardware tokens for high-value transactions (e.g., prepaid energy top-ups).
  • Immutable Audit Logs: Blockchain-adjacent ledgers tracking all access attempts and modifications to billing records.
  • Blockchain and Smart Contracts in Pay-as-You-Go

    Blockchain technology introduces decentralization and automation to PayG models, particularly in scenarios requiring trustless transactions or peer-to-peer (P2P) exchanges. Smart contracts—self-executing agreements coded on blockchains like Ethereum or Hyperledger—enable automated microtransactions without intermediaries. Applications span energy trading, decentralized software billing, and microloans, though adoption faces challenges related to scalability, regulatory ambiguity, and user familiarity.

    Use Cases for Smart Contracts in PayG

  • Peer-to-Peer Energy Trading: Platforms like Power Ledger or Brooklyn Microgrid use smart contracts to facilitate solar panel owners selling excess energy to neighbors, with payments settled automatically via cryptocurrency or fiat.
  • Decentralized SaaS Billing: Services like Gitcoin Grants or BrightID employ smart contracts to distribute micro-payments to contributors based on usage metrics (e.g., API calls, storage space).
  • Microloans and PayG Financing: Startups such as Kiva or LendChain leverage blockchain to disburse small loans with repayments tied to IoT-verified usage (e.g., agricultural equipment rental).
  • Pros and Cons of Blockchain in PayG

    Industry Payment Frequency Scalability Challenges Consumer vs. Business Adoption Barriers Revenue Model Variations
    B2CTelecom, Utilities, SaaS (Freemium)
    • High-frequency (daily/weekly): Prepaid airtime, utility meters.
    • Low-frequency (monthly/quarterly): SaaS subscriptions, streaming services.
    • Fragmented payment rails: Cash, mobile money, cards, bank transfers.
    • High churn risk: Price sensitivity in discretionary spending (e.g., gaming SaaS).
    • Regulatory compliance: KYC/AML for micro-transactions (e.g., M-Pesa’s $1 limit in Kenya).
    • Consumers:
      • Lack of financial literacy (e.g., over-payment in PayG solar).
      • Trust issues with digital payments (e.g., mobile money fraud in Africa).
      • Behavioral inertia (preference for upfront ownership).
    • Businesses:
      • Complex procurement processes (e.g., enterprise SaaS approvals).
      • Resistance to usage-based pricing (perceived as unpredictable).
      • Integration costs with legacy systems (e.g., ERP software).
    • Tiered pricing: Free tier → PayG → Subscription (e.g., Zoom).
    • Pay-per-unit: Telecom (per MB), utilities (per kWh), SaaS (per API call).
    • Bundling: Data + voice (e.g., Airtel’s "Happy Hours").
    Advantages Challenges
    • Trustless Transactions: Eliminates reliance on centralized billing systems, reducing fraud and operational costs.
    • Automation: Smart contracts enforce terms without manual intervention, improving efficiency for high-volume PayG models.
    • Transparency: Immutable ledgers provide audit trails for disputes, enhancing compliance and user confidence.
    • Global Accessibility: Enables cross-border PayG without currency conversion delays or intermediary fees.
    • Scalability Limits: Public blockchains (e.g., Ethereum) struggle with high transaction volumes, leading to latency or high gas fees.
    • Regulatory Uncertainty: Lack of standardized frameworks for blockchain-based billing, particularly around tax reporting and consumer protections.
    • User Complexity: Cryptographic wallets and private keys introduce barriers for non-technical users.
    • Interoperability Gaps: Integration with traditional payment systems (e.g., credit cards) requires hybrid architectures, increasing complexity.
    Hybrid Models as a Compromise
    Many PayG systems adopt hybrid approaches, combining blockchain for high-value or P2P transactions with traditional backend systems for scalability. For example:
  • Layer 2 Solutions: Using Polygon or Lightning Network to reduce blockchain congestion for microtransactions.
  • Oracle Integration: Feeding IoT data (e.g., electricity meter readings) into smart contracts via Chainlink oracles to trigger payments.
  • Regulatory Sandboxes: Testing blockchain-PayG pilots in controlled environments (e.g., Singapore’s Project Ubin) before full deployment.
  • IoT and Edge Computing in Real-Time Pay-as-You-Go

    The Internet of Things (IoT) and edge computing are foundational to PayG models that require instantaneous data processing, such as electricity metering, ride-sharing, or industrial equipment rental. IoT devices—ranging from smart meters to connected vehicles—generate continuous streams of usage data, while edge computing processes this data locally to minimize latency. However, challenges such as connectivity instability in remote areas, device fragmentation, and real-time analytics demands necessitate careful infrastructure design.

    IoT Enablers for PayG

  • Smart Meters and Sensors: Devices like Landis+Gyr or Itron meters transmit kilowatt-hour readings every 15 minutes, enabling dynamic electricity pricing.
  • Connected Vehicles: Telematics units in cars (e.g., Geotab, Verizon Connect) track mileage, fuel consumption, or idle time for PayG insurance or car-sharing models.
  • Industrial IoT: Factory sensors monitor equipment usage (e.g., Siemens MindSphere) to bill clients per operational hour or material consumption.
  • Wearable and Health Devices: Fitness trackers

    Pay-as-you-go is more than a billing mechanism; it is a paradigm shift that redefines access, scalability, and financial inclusion in the digital age. By decoupling cost from commitment, PayG empowers users—from individual consumers in underserved markets to enterprises managing variable workloads—to optimize spending while providers benefit from predictable revenue streams and reduced churn. The technological advancements underpinning PayG, from dynamic pricing algorithms to blockchain-based automation, further expand its potential, particularly in sectors like IoT and shared economies where usage patterns are inherently volatile. As adoption grows, the model’s greatest challenge lies in balancing innovation with infrastructure resilience, ensuring equitable access without compromising profitability. Ultimately, PayG exemplifies how flexibility and technology can converge to create sustainable, user-centric service models.

  • FAQ

    What does "PAYG withholding" mean in taxes?

    PAYG (Pay As You Go) withholding is a system where employers deduct tax from an employee’s salary or wages before paying them, then remit it to the tax authority (like the ATO in Australia). It ensures tax is paid gradually rather than in one lump sum at year-end. Freelancers or self-employed individuals may also make voluntary PAYG withholding payments.

    How does PAYG tax work for individuals?

    PAYG tax is a progressive tax system where tax is deducted automatically from your income (e.g., salary, wages, or investment income) as it’s earned. For employees, this is done via withholding; for self-employed or business owners, it may involve quarterly instalments. The goal is to reduce the need for large end-of-year tax bills.

    What is a PAYG instalment and how does it work?

    A PAYG instalment is a quarterly tax payment made by businesses, self-employed individuals, or investors to cover expected tax liabilities for the year. The ATO calculates the amount based on past income or business activity, and payments are due by specific deadlines (e.g., March, June, September, December). Missing instalments can trigger penalties.

    What does PAYG on Schedule 5 refer to in tax returns?

    PAYG on Schedule 5 refers to the section of an Australian tax return where individuals report their private health insurance (PHI) rebate and Medicare levy surcharge calculations. It also includes details of PAYG withholding from investments (e.g., dividends, interest) that weren’t already pre-filled by the ATO.

    What is a PAYG payment summary, and who receives one?

    A PAYG payment summary is a document issued by employers or payers to employees or recipients showing the total income paid and tax withheld during the financial year. Employees use it to complete their tax return, while the ATO pre-fills this data where possible. It includes gross payments, withholding amounts, and sometimes superannuation contributions.

    What is a PAYG income tax instalment for self-employed people?

    A PAYG income tax instalment is a quarterly tax payment required for self-employed individuals, sole traders, or small businesses to cover their expected annual tax liability. The ATO calculates the instalment based on past income or business performance, and payments are due in advance (e.g., April, July, October, January). It helps avoid a large tax bill at year-end.